UK scientists help solve mystery of why comets emit X-rays

12 March 2018

The mystery of why comets travelling through Space give off X-ray emissions has been solved thanks to new research undertaken by a team that included science staff from STFC’s Central Laser Facility (CLF) and RAL Space.

Scientists have long wondered why comets can radiate X-rays, given that X-rays are normally associated with hot objects like the Sun but comets are among the coldest objects in the Solar system.

When comets travel through the Solar system they interact with the Solar radiation, the Solar wind and the Solar magnetic field. This interaction produces a visible atmosphere or coma around the comet and the observed cometary tail, and in some cases produces X-rays. These X-rays are generated on the Sunward side of the comet where the Solar wind impacts the cometary atmosphere forming a bow shock.

To investigate how X-rays can be emitted from a comet, a team of scientists from 15 research institutes performed experiments at the LULI laser facility in Paris where they replicated the interaction of the Solar-wind with a comet.

The STFC team involved in the project were instrumental in coming up with the scientific model for the interaction of the solar wind with the comet. This included the theoretical model for the generation of plasma turbulence, the acceleration of electrons by the turbulence and the X-ray emission from the accelerated electrons. The STFC team also supported a team from the University of Oxford in numerical simulations and undertook the target fabrication.

CLF’s Professor Bob Bingham led the STFC team involved in the project and said:
“This work highlights the important role laboratory astrophysics experiments play in unravelling complex plasma processes operating in distant astrophysical objects.”

Other members of the STFC team included CLF’s Dr Raoul Trines and Chris Spindloe and from STFC’s RAL Space facility Dr Ruth Bamford.

CLF theorist Dr Raoul Trines said of the project:
“What has been very exciting in this research has been the way we have been able to replicate in a laboratory an incredibly powerful astrophysical force of nature and to improve our understanding of it.”

For the experiments the research team fired laser beams onto a plastic foil, which exploded, causing a stream of electrons and ions to be expelled, forming a high speed flow of ionized gas (plasma) like the Solar wind. This ‘plasma flow’ then impacted onto a solid sphere, the so-called laboratory `comet’, placed nearly a centimetre away from the plastic foil, resembles what happens when a real comet passes through the Solar system. It was found that electrons are heated to about a million degrees in the up-stream plasma by plasma turbulence.

These hot electrons are responsible for emitting X-rays but only in the presence of a magnetic field.

This work also sheds light on a cosmic ray mystery known as the injection problem. It is widely recognised that strong shock waves are expected to accelerate particles to very high energies, however, they require a source of particles fast enough to cross the shock, the injection problem. Each time the particles cross the shock they gain energy. This latest experiment clearly demonstrates that plasma turbulence can provide a source of fast particles overcoming the injection problem.

From the space science point of view, this research has been important in better understanding the mechanisms that create cosmic rays. The most hazardous cosmic rays are the energetic particles either from the Sun or outside the Solar system. They can penetrate even thick walls like tiny bullets and present a very serious hazard to both astronauts and spacecraft technology. Billions of pounds can be at risk due to Space Weather (as it is known) damaging satellites. Astronauts on long term missions outside the Earth’s magnetosphere could receive life threatening doses of radiation from such particles. In order to protect them we need to understand how this radiation is created so we can predict it and give warnings or even shield against it using similar mechanisms to that which created it.

A laboratory experiment like this enables us to test our understanding of how cosmic rays are accelerated to such high energies, in a controlled environment. Something that is not easy to do directly in space.

The paper has been published in Nature Physics.


Jake Gilmore, Media Manager, STFC
Tel: +44 (0) 1793 442092
Mob: +44 (0) 7970 994586

Notes to editors

The Central Laser Facility (CLF) at STFC’s Rutherford Appleton Laboratory is one of the world’s leading laser facilities providing scientists from the UK and Europe with an unparalleled range of state-of-the-art laser technology. The CLF’s wide ranging applications include experiments in physics, chemistry and biology, accelerating subatomic particles to high energies, probing chemical reactions on the shortest timescales and studying biochemical and biophysical process critical to life itself.

From advanced, compact, tuneable lasers which can pinpoint individual particles to high power laser installations that recreate the conditions inside stars, a vigorous development programme ensures that our facilities maintain their international competitiveness.

STFC RAL Space is an integral part of the Science and Technology Facilities Council's (STFC) Rutherford Appleton Laboratory (RAL). RAL Space carries out world-class space research and technology development with involvement in over 210 space missions to date.

Last updated: 19 March 2018


Science and Technology Facilities Council
Switchboard: +44 (0)1793 442000